School Report CardK-8 SchoolMemphis-Shelby County Schools

Caldwell-Guthrie

Shelby County, Tennessee

F
Needs Improvement

1.2 / 5.0

F1.2 / 5.0
Needs Improvement

K-8 School · 2024-25

Overall Performance Summary

Caldwell-Guthrie earned an overall grade of F with a score of 1.2 out of 5.0, placing it among the bottom quarter of k-8 schools in Shelby County. The school ranks #224 out of 242 schools in the county, compared to a county average score of 3.1.

This rating indicates that Caldwell-Guthrie is facing significant challenges in meeting the state's accountability standards and may benefit from targeted support and intervention.

Needs ImprovementFNeeds ImprovementFAverageC

How This Grade Was Calculated

Tennessee calculates each school’s letter grade using a weighted combination of performance indicators. Each component is scored on a 1–5 scale and assigned a letter grade.

50% weight

Needs Improvement

F
1.0/ 5.0

Measures the percentage of students scoring On Track or Mastered on state assessments in ELA, math, science, and social studies.

40% weight

Needs Improvement

F
1.0/ 5.0

Tracks how much academic progress all students made over the school year, regardless of their starting point.

10% weight

Average

C
3.0/ 5.0

Focuses specifically on growth among the lowest-performing 25% of students, ensuring schools support those who need it most.

Weighted Contribution to Final Grade

F 50%
F 40%
C 10%

The final score of 1.2is calculated by multiplying each component’s score by its weight percentage and summing the results. A higher weight means that component has a larger influence on the overall grade.

Subject Proficiency

Percentage of students scoring On Track or Mastered on TNReady assessments.

Across all tested subjects, an average of 6.0% of students at Caldwell-Guthrie demonstrated proficiency. The strongest performance was in ELA (Elementary) at 6.5%, while Science (Elementary) at 5.2% represents the greatest opportunity for growth.

50%+ Proficient 30-49% Proficient Below 30%

ELA (Elementary): 6.5% of students scored On Track or Mastered, highlighting a significant area of need.

Science (Elementary): 5.2% of students scored On Track or Mastered, highlighting a significant area of need.

Science (Middle): 6.3% of students scored On Track or Mastered, highlighting a significant area of need.

Growth Indicators

Year-over-year academic growth measured on a 1–5 scale using TVAAS data.

Caldwell-Guthrie shows limited overall academic growth with an average score of 1.5 out of 5.0 across measured subjects. This suggests students are making less than expected progress and the school may need to focus on instructional strategies that accelerate learning.

Literacy

3.0
of 5.0

Meeting expectations

Numeracy

1.0
of 5.0

Below expectations

Science

1.0
of 5.0

Below expectations

Social Studies

1.0
of 5.0

Below expectations

How Does Caldwell-Guthrie Compare?

Overall score compared to the Shelby County average and the Tennessee state average.

With a score of 1.2, Caldwell-Guthrie is below the Shelby County average of 3.1 and well below the statewide average of 3.4. Among 242 schools in Shelby County, this school holds the #224 position.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Caldwell-Guthrie’s performance data.

What grade did Caldwell-Guthrie receive?
Caldwell-Guthrie received an overall grade of F (Needs Improvement) with a score of 1.2 out of 5.0 for the 2024-25 school year. This grade is determined by the Tennessee Department of Education based on student achievement, growth, and growth of the lowest-performing students.
How does Caldwell-Guthrie compare to other Shelby County schools?
Caldwell-Guthrie ranks #224 out of 242 schools in Shelby County. The county average score is 3.1, and Caldwell-Guthrie’s score of 1.2 is below that average. The school has opportunities to close the gap with higher-performing schools in the county.
What does the growth score mean for Caldwell-Guthrie?
Growth scores measure how much academic progress students made compared to similar students across Tennessee. Caldwell-Guthrie’s average growth score of 1.5 out of 5.0 indicates limited year-over-year progress. A score below 3.0 means students are growing slower than expected, which can compound over time.
Is Caldwell-Guthrie above or below the state average?
Caldwell-Guthrie’s score of 1.2 is well below the approximate Tennessee state average of 3.4. This means the school has room to improve to reach the statewide benchmark.
Which subjects are strongest at Caldwell-Guthrie?
The highest proficiency rate is in ELA (Elementary) at 6.5%, while the lowest is in Science (Elementary) at 5.2%. Across all 3 tested areas, the average proficiency rate is 6.0%.

View Official Report Card

See the complete report from the Tennessee Department of Education.

TN Report Card
All Shelby County SchoolsTennessee School Grades

Data from the Tennessee Department of Education | 2024-25 School Year