Seven Tennessee school districts had at least 70 percent of their third graders meet the state’s reading bar last spring, the goal every district must plan toward under the state’s school funding law.¶
That’s according to a Tennessee Firefly analysis of district results from the Tennessee Department of Education. Statewide, 44.9 percent of third graders met or exceeded expectations in English language arts (ELA) on the Tennessee Comprehensive Assessment Program (TCAP), the best result since at least 2017.¶
Of the 141 districts with reported results, Arlington led at 79.7 percent, followed by Williamson County at 76.3 percent and Collierville at 75.7 percent. University Schools (75.6 percent), Germantown (75.1 percent), Alamo (73 percent), and Maryville (71.8 percent) also cleared the mark.¶
Together, those seven districts accounted for 4,824 of the 71,791 third grade ELA scores counted statewide, about 7 percent. Lakeland just missed at 69.3 percent.¶
The Tennessee Investment in Student Achievement (TISA) Act requires every district to file an annual accountability report that sets achievement targets, among them having 70 percent of third graders meet the ELA bar. This year’s reports were due to the state by November 1.¶
Metro Nashville’s report, on the agenda for its school board’s November 10 meeting, sets 2038 as the year to reach 70 percent.¶
Far From the Goal
Forty-one districts were at 50 percent or higher, while 10 were below 30 percent. The lowest was Humboldt City Schools in Gibson County, where 17.4 percent of the 69 third graders tested met the bar, followed by Fayette County at 24.1 percent.¶
The state’s two largest districts also have a long way to go. In Memphis-Shelby County Schools (MSCS), 31.8 percent of third graders met the bar, and in Metro Nashville Public Schools (MNPS), 35.5 percent did.¶
Compared to 2025, third grade results rose in 101 districts, fell in 39, and held steady in one.¶
When the statewide results came out in June, Governor Bill Lee credited the state’s education spending.¶
“Tennessee’s strategic investments in education have led to promising progress for students in multiple subjects and grade levels,” wrote Governor Lee.¶
The results also drew praise from education advocacy organization Tennesseans for Student Success (TSS), which pointed to years of investment in literacy and learning recovery.¶
“Tennessee students are succeeding today because leaders chose to champion meaningful investments in the classroom year after year,” wrote Lana Skelo, TSS President and CEO.¶
The Tennessee Firefly is a project of and supported by Tennesseans for Student Success.¶
The Three-Year Step
State law also sets a nearer target. The TISA Progress Review Board, which includes the commissioner of education, the State Board of Education chair, and four members appointed by the speakers of the Senate and House, must set a minimum goal for each district.¶
That goal is to close 15 percent of the gap between a district’s 2022-23 results and 70 percent within three years. It doesn’t apply to districts that were already at 70 percent or higher.¶
Last spring’s tests marked the third year. Applying that formula to each district’s 2022-23 rate in the state’s public data, the Tennessee Firefly found 62 of the 131 districts that started below 70 percent reached their step, and 69 did not.¶
MSCS cleared its step, climbing from 24 percent in 2022-23 to 31.8 percent. Knox County also made it, while MNPS, Hamilton County, and Rutherford County fell short.¶
Nine districts finished within half a percentage point of their step, so small differences in the starting figures districts use could change the count.¶
What Happens Next
The Progress Review Board reviews every district’s report each year to determine whether the district is “taking the proper steps to achieve the goal,” as state law puts it.¶
When a district misses its goal at the end of a three-year period, state law directs the board to decide whether further action is needed. The board can then recommend that the commissioner require the district to complete training on budgeting to raise student achievement.¶





