Members of the Tennessee State Board of Education are scheduled to take final votes Friday on rules that govern changes to public charter school agreements and the closure of failing virtual schools.¶
The board meets at 9 a.m. in the auditorium of the Alvin C. York Agricultural Institute in Jamestown. Members accepted both sets of rules unanimously on first reading in August, and the meeting agenda notes changes to each since then.¶
Charter Amendment Rules Return
The charter rules would move the process for amending a charter agreement back into the State Board’s own rules. The repeal of the board’s earlier amendment rule took effect in 2022, and the full process now sits in the rules of the Tennessee Public Charter School Commission.¶
The board has not posted the final version of the charter rules. Under the version members accepted in August, the application steps would return to the State Board while appeals stay with the Commission. State Board staff wrote that the split is meant to “distinguish responsibilities of the two state agencies.”¶
A charter school needs its authorizer’s approval to add or drop grades or a transportation plan, change who governs or manages it, move outside its approved area, change its academic focus, or enroll beyond the limits in its agreement. As under the Commission’s current rule, a complete request that gets no ruling within 60 days of its deadline would be approved automatically.¶
The rules would also carry out parts of this year’s charter law, Public Chapter 1012, including a change that lets each public charter school’s governing board set the order of its own lottery preferences.¶
Charter schools are free public schools operated by a non-profit entity under a “charter” with a school district or the state. Charter agreements are generally centered around the principle that charter schools may enjoy more flexibility and autonomy than traditional public schools, and in exchange, the charter schools agree to higher accountability and potential closure if they fail to meet standards.¶
Closing Failing Virtual Schools
The virtual school rule carries out Public Chapter 905, a law passed in April. A district must close a virtual school it established if the school lands on a state priority school list after 2025, or if it earns the lowest growth rating, “significantly below expectations,” three years in a row starting with 2025-26.¶
Under the rule, the district must give the school 30 days’ written notice before voting to close it, and the school can’t enroll new students after that notice. Families must be told in writing within a week of the vote and learn their other public school options within 30 days.¶
No one commented on the virtual school rule at a public hearing last month, but board members suggested changes since August to the yearly evaluation districts complete for their virtual schools. A virtual school that earns an F on its School Letter Grade would have its academic outcomes rated “Below Expectations,” and starting in 2027-28, the evaluation would weigh three years of letter grades.¶
Board member Dr. Ina Maxwell questioned those evaluations in August, when the Tennessee Department of Education presented its annual report on virtual education, the Tennessee Firefly reported at the time.¶
“Families can be told their school is ‘meeting expectations’ at the very moment the state is classifying it among its lowest performers,” said Maxwell.¶
Crystal McCarver, who presented the report for the department, said it had revised the monitoring tool to reflect that concern.¶
That report found 27 percent of the state’s public virtual schools posted a growth rating of Level 3 or higher in 2024-25, compared with 66 percent of other public schools.¶
The rule also points districts to enrollment caps in Public Chapter 1040, another 2026 law. A district’s virtual schools may enroll no more than 1,500 students combined, or its 2025-26 total if it already had one, unless each posts a growth rating of at least “at expectations.”¶
Education advocacy organization Tennesseans for Student Success (TSS) supported the closure law this year, along with the charter law’s automatic renewals for certain high-performing public charter schools. In a policy brief, TSS wrote that virtual schools “should be held to high standards to ensure families have high quality school choice options.”¶
The Tennessee Firefly is a project of and supported by Tennesseans for Student Success.¶





