Many states across the nation are grappling with how to answer the ever-changing educational needs of students, and some have turned to models of diversifying education, both internally and through school choice. But beyond the discussions of educational need that often encase school choice debates, the movement and success of school choice legislation in some states has made for some odd intellectual bedfellows.¶
One of the best and purest examples happens to come from Tennessee. Over the past legislative sessions, Tennessee lawmakers have passed legislation that offers parents more control over where their child attends school through an “opportunity scholarship.” Publicly, you will see this referred to as the “voucher program,” although the scholarship fails to meet the definition of a voucher, offering no direct stipend to families. During the debates around the legislation and since its passage, vitriol against the program has created these odd bedfellows in resistance. What is most interesting, perhaps alarming to some, is the embrace of traditionally progressive ideas over traditionally conservative ones when it comes to how children are educated.¶
This bedfellow arrangement may have been best displayed in a publication of the TriStar Daily by owner and editor Steve Gill, when he coauthored a piece with a teacher association director named J.C. Bowman. In their article, they capture and articulate progressive concepts that are often regurgitated by other opponents on social media. But the article presents a great opportunity to consider these stated objections, their roots, and why, despite the claims of the authors, they are an example of moving the goalposts on conservative principles rather than a commitment to them.¶
Let’s start with the core claims of the authors.
¶
Choice vs. Subsidy?
Gill and Bowman make the case that tax dollars belong to the public. They call scholarships “taxpayer money” and “private-school tuition” subsidies, and say “public money requires public accountability.” The premise is that once it’s collected, the money belongs to the system. But conservatives have long argued that though government collects it, it’s the citizens’ money, raised to educate children, and parents are taxpayers too. A scholarship is just as likely to return part of a family’s own contribution to the purpose it was raised for, especially if that family pays a greater portion of the tax base. One cannot subsidize oneself. Further, government shouldn’t pat itself on the back when it appropriately delivers on a constitutional right, as education is for every child under the Tennessee Constitution. No, the only subsidizing that has taken place in education has been of the public system by taxpayers who have never used it, including taxpayers who have been paying private school tuition while their tax dollars are exclusively redistributed to public schools. If anything, the opportunity scholarship is reducing the subsidizing use of tax dollars.¶
Milton Friedman, a saint of conservative economics, wrote in “The Role of Government in Education” (1955) and Capitalism and Freedom (1962) that paying for education and running schools are separate questions. The state can fund a child’s education without operating the building. He proposed vouchers, arguing that government could finance education while parents chose who provides it. That answers the “choice versus subsidy” claim, from a conservative standpoint, pretty directly.¶
Money to a Child and Parent, or to a System?
In their article, Gill and Bowman drift away from the issue of choice and venture into a criticism of how public schools are funded under the state’s TISA (Tennessee Investment in Student Achievement) formula. They argue TISA “follows students” but public school costs don’t, so districts need protection for bus routes, roofs, and staff when students leave. That puts preserving the institution ahead of the needs of a student, a flip in conservative thinking about what the role of education is in the first place. John Locke wrote of this dynamic in the chapter “Of Paternal Power” in his Second Treatise of Government (1690), where he argues that a father “may put the tuition of his son in other hands” while the child’s duty to the parent “remains never the less entire.” In other words, the school acts as the parent’s delegate, and authority over the child’s education stays with the parent. The U.S. Supreme Court affirmed this premise in Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925), ruling that a child “is not the mere creature of the State.”¶
Students do not exist to cover the costs of government. They are not checks to be counted by districts. The TISA formula acknowledges this to a degree, creating a system of support that follows a student to cover the student’s needs, not the district’s or school’s. This idea is not novel. Adam Smith reasoned long ago in The Wealth of Nations (1776) that a teacher whose pay doesn’t depend on his pupils will neglect them. Even so, the scholarship program passed in Tennessee holds schools harmless from student disenrollment, meaning the program cannot affect the amount of state funding they receive. Yet Gill and Bowman tie the program to the closure of schools in key districts, a very misleading claim.¶
The right to a publicly funded education rests with the child in Tennessee, but Gill and Bowman’s argument builds on the progressive tradition of John Dewey. In Democracy and Education (1916), Dewey argued for using schools to standardize the social environment of the child, writing that the school should give each individual “an opportunity to escape from the limitations of the social group in which he was born.” He had earlier gone so far, in “My Pedagogic Creed” (1897), as to call the teacher “the prophet of the true God.” This progressive logic traces back to the early justifications of the common schools by progressives like Horace Mann, who called public education “the great equalizer of the conditions of men” (Twelfth Annual Report, 1848). But this equalizing has always been antithetical to the conservative quest for educational diversification. Most conservative parents see “standardization” and equity initiatives as social indoctrination, not education. Conservative educational diversity requires funding that both considers the specific needs of the student and follows the student to where that need can be met. This is the spirit behind both the TISA formula and the Opportunity Scholarship.¶
Who Deserves It?
Gill and Bowman overtly argue that choice doesn’t and shouldn’t benefit the wealthy. They state that “eligibility is not the same thing as demonstrated need,” which frames education aid as welfare for the poor rather than a universal right of every family to direct its own share. This is known as “means testing,” and conservative thinkers have historically rejected it, especially when it comes to how government delivers universal and constitutional rights. Milton Friedman made this point most clearly in “The Role of Government in Education” (1955), where, on school choice specifically, he favored universal vouchers for every family. He saw choice as a parental right, not poverty relief, and argued that universal programs build broader public support and avoid stigma.¶
But the resistance goes beyond mere economics. It touches the very nature of how aggressive and invasive government should be when it comes to family financial privacy, and it assumes that any family wealth is accessible to the student. I have often noted that no scholarship recipient has any net worth of their own, and any consideration of what their family might have holds a child’s right hostage to a measure of family wealth the child has no guaranteed access to. Any inquiry into a family’s means to justify the access their child has to a constitutional right is inappropriately invasive and assumptive, and neither makes for good policy.¶
Accountable to Whom?
Gill and Bowman ultimately say they find the program lacking in accountability, asserting that the lack is an intentional smokescreen to avoid analysis. They argue private schools should be held to “comparable” state academic reporting. School choice conservatives see the parent’s power to leave as the main form of accountability, and they treat state testing mandates as the road to regulating¶
private schools into public ones. But beyond that simple fear, this claim harkens back to who should be in control in the first place: the parent or the system? As previously outlined, conservatives have long supported the parent’s right to control the process and the parent’s ability to determine the course of action that will best meet the needs of their children. If a conservative position puts parents in control of tax dollars they hold in trust with the state to provide a right their children possess, then accountability to any entity outside the family only serves to meddle. Educational diversity cannot be achieved by making everyone the same, as the progressive common school movement endeavored to do. Forcing the same test and curriculum on every school doesn’t create choice for families. It guts it. Different schools need to be able to offer different approaches to the same standard, and that means assessing in alignment with each approach. Standards still remain for program participation, and private schools consent to them, but any further redistribution of power to the state only restricts families who use more than academic data to make educational decisions.¶
Gill and Bowman also call for equal accountability but do not call for equal investment. The excess funding public schools receive through TISA weights, along with provided facilities, funded retirement, and employee benefits, far outpaces what private schools receive. For a conservative position on this, look no further than the words of Christ himself: “For unto whomsoever much is given, of him shall be much required” (Luke 12:48).¶
Though Gill and Bowman make a number of other spurious claims in their “Gish gallop” against school choice, the claim that their position is “conservative” lacks a historical and philosophical foundation. Conservative families in Tennessee support school choice. They want to be able to navigate the nuances of their child’s educational right, and they feel that if that navigation takes them off the course of public education, they shouldn’t be anchored to it. But beyond public sentiment, we must begin recognizing that intellectual, historical, and philosophical honesty matters and, to quote Gill and Bowman, shouldn’t become secondary to “political slogans.” In that spirit, I find arguments that liberal policies are better for education than conservative ones more fair and honest than those of these odd bedfellows who tout progressive ideas as conservative policy.¶
This article was written by a guest contributor. Views do not necessarily express the positions of the Tennessee Firefly or any related entities. ¶






